why spellrack failed to balance
Spellrack failed because racking occurred after list selection, offering asymmetrical information and encouraging repetitive selections of top-tier spells.
- Selecting racked spells after seeing the opponent's list choice created an information imbalance, allowing players to counter-pick defensive spells
- Spellrack led to repetitive lists because players consistently chose the strongest available spells such as Carnage or Wind Wall
- The mechanic only applied to newly released armies, preventing players of older armies from accessing it
- Spellrack could have functioned better if balanced by point costs during list construction rather than after list selection
- Tying spellrack points to battlegroup cohorts was suggested, though players noted this would negatively impact gargantuans and colossal models


