GOTY nominee limits and contenders
Members debate the standard six-game Game of the Year nomination cap, questioning unreleased titles, remakes, and licensed contenders.
- Game of the Year typically limits nominees to six titles, though members argue a crowded year warrants expanding the category to include indie games
- Nominating unreleased or recently released massive titles like GTA 6 draws skepticism, as players lack time to finish and evaluate them fairly before voting
- Inclusion of remakes and licensed games faces criticism over potential alternatives like Nioh 3 or Ace Combat
- A 007 game is defended as worthy of a top-six nomination due to its standout hand-to-hand combat, despite skepticism from others


