- Ducks only pose a major threat if they have a 5x or more metal advantage over the anti-sub fleet and are sent in with short/no advance notice, beelining recklessly towards the base.
- If ducks stop or lack a metal advantage, they die via attrition; emergency torpedoing the base can also halt their push and lead to attrition kills.

Beyond All Reason | BAR
Join players and developers to talk strategy, share ideas, report bugs, and shape the future of the game.
17,324 Online
77,399 Members
🎓|academy-chat
Summarized from recent messages. Can get things wrong.
- The mine layer assisting other builders is currently an "abusable weapon style" and a potential design issue.
- The inability of a unit to finish a build if interrupted was intended behavior due to its tags, not a bug.
- A core problem is making players not want to mass-produce cheap fighters while still needing air superiority for threats.
- Suggestions include making planes more survivable against fighters, or introducing specialized, expensive fighters with unique abilities like extended range or all-directional firing.
- The current T2 fast submarine firing arc (90 degrees) roughly matches T1 subs, but website descriptions indicate an intended 'wider arc'.
- A developer is asked to investigate if this discrepancy is a bug or a balance change, and if the visually drawn arc should match the actual fire arc, or vice versa.
- An opponent managed to build 4 LLTs (Laser Light Towers) with Dragon's Teeth and a Warden early in the game, specifically before the halfway point, right at the player's base.
- The surprised player questioned how the opponent could afford such defenses while simultaneously making combat units (specifically 5 grunts).
- Assault subs (Predators) can out-range and out-speed destroyers (Cor Des), firing at 90 degrees from forward to shoot and then retreat, preventing destroyers from catching up or landing depth charges effectively.
- Subs can similarly counter ducks (amphibious units) because eels (ARM subs) out-range and out-speed them, allowing for a shot-and-retreat strategy by moving in circles.
- One player questions how geo sea can T2 faster than opponents to punish dolphin builds, especially when geo sea's strategy often involves a skater dolphin destroyer open.
- A 'turtle beach sea' strategy involves building T2 mexes before engaging in sea combat, potentially mirroring geo sea's own greed for resources.
- The original question is when players can develop their own style versus just learning the "correct" way to play through emulation.
- A player suggests that around 30-35 OS (Overall Score) is where players understand enough fundamentals to start breaking the meta with non-standard styles.
- A player around 25-30 OS is expected to have an effective personal style, unlike low OS players whose "styles" might just be fundamental mistakes, such as building static artillery in their spawn base.
- A defensive style for a 30 OS player could involve a vehicle open with safer expansion, leading into a timing attack with a specific unit composition, while also understanding which maps suit this approach.
- A hotkey trainer exists to practice hotkeys without loading into a game, with different difficulty settings (Noob, Mid, Commander) for varying levels of complexity.
- High APM (Actions Per Minute) is less critical in BAR compared to other RTS games; players can win tournaments with effective APMs as low as 30-33, especially if macroing skills are strong.
- On Failed Negotiations, every starting position is defensible, and even losing sea control doesn't lead to 100% domination, requiring land units to engage for victory.
- Spawn areas on Failed Negotiations are not directly next to water, preventing early economic destruction from sea units.
- The 'Jade Empress' map is characterized by its super mountainous terrain, four front canyons, and being surrounded by sea, leading to chaotic gameplay.
- Some players find the map 'absolutely awful' yet love it, while others experience team surrenders before they can fully evaluate it.
- Players often stick to a few popular maps (e.g., Rosetta, ATG) and frequently skip maps with significant water features, despite a large selection of diverse maps being available.
- One suggested solution to promote map diversity is a 'seasonal map list' tied to ranked play, where maps from previous seasons are excluded from the current one to prevent overlap.
- Mines, including light mines, deal their full damage to everything except other mines, specifically, a light mine deals only 1 damage to other mines.
- The game's AoE damage calculation is complex, involving AoE radius, 'edge effectiveness' (percentage of damage at max AoE extent), and a damage falloff curve.
- The Twin Guard has higher overall DPS (around 60 more than a Beamer) because it has two turrets, but one of its turrets only has 400 range compared to the other's 490, effectively halving its DPS at longer ranges.
- Beamers are considered better for area control/denial, buying time, and are particularly effective against rockets, while Twin Guards are better for direct assaults and fighting units 'to the death' due to their higher health and gap-closed DPS.
- A BAR bot construction unit (bot con) costs 120 resources and takes 23 seconds to build (often half with commander boosting), then can immediately construct mexes that generate 120 resources per minute for a 50 metal investment.
- In contrast, a StarCraft 2 Terran Command Center costs 300 minerals and 50 seconds, only granting the ability to train workers that cost 50 minerals each to extract ~40 resources per minute.
- T2 air is for a 'handful' of massively overpowered stealth fighters that can flank enemy air, not for spamming.
- T1 fighters are better for an 'air wall' due to their visibility on radar, deterring approaches, while T2 stealth fighters remain unseen.
- The fusion rework, which occurred 8 months prior (S3 balance patch), made fusions across all factions cheaper to build initially but less metal efficient overall.
- This change means getting the first few fusions online is faster, but the efficiency gap with advanced fusions (AFUS) is even greater.
- The optimal number of Tumbleweeds is debated; some suggest 5-7 to avoid wasting metal, while others use up to 15 to counter mid-tier 2 units.
- Tumbleweeds are considered powerful due to their large area-of-effect (AoE) which allows them to hit multiple grunts and even kill 10 thugs for only 60 metal.
- Tremors are expensive (50k energy) and their high cost makes them difficult to justify in most situations, as resources could be better spent elsewhere.
- Tremors are easily countered by 'going around' them, using air or sea units, or by simply out-ranging them with units like Starlights if supported by anti-spam.

