defining player skill
The definition of 'good' and 'bad' players is subjective and comparative, not objective, and depends on the reference population or an individual's rating (OS).
- The idea that everyone below the top 0.01% is 'objectively bad' is an elitist view; objective statements should account for the majority position to have useful meaning.
- A more useful way to define 'good' or 'bad' is in comparison to a player's own OS (overall skill) rating, for example, 'this guy is super bad for his OS'.
- The rating model itself is probabilistic, and being worse than only a few top players doesn't automatically mean a player is 'bad at all'.
- Examples of 'bad for OS' behavior include spamming wind turbines on Supreme Commander for OS gain, then playing poorly on the front line with minimal units and excessive metal in wind.


